W I G N A L L
Six of the Best - Coming-of-Age Novels
This is a difficult one for several reasons. Firstly, there are a few well-known books out there that are mentioned almost automatically in relation to coming-of-age novels (step up Mr Salinger, Mr Dickens, Ms Lee). Secondly, our perception of what constitutes “coming-of-age” has changed. Most people now think of such books as covering either the end of childhood or more likely, the journey through adolescence into adulthood. One of my favourite novels, The Red Badge of Courage by Stephen Crane is a coming-of-age novel, as is another favourite, Brideshead Revisited by Evelyn Waugh and yet I’ve left both out because they deal with young men rather than adolescents. So in the spirit of the coming-of-age novel as we now know it, as an exploration of the journey between childhood and adulthood, of what we take with us and what we leave behind, here is my list for you to ponder.
I Capture the Castle by Dodie Smith
Because Smith subsequently wrote the children’s classic, The Hundred and One Dalmatians, her first novel is also generally viewed as being for children. It’s certainly been cherished by generations of young girls but it’s a terrible shame that it isn’t more widely enjoyed because it’s a wonderful novel of English eccentricity and American sensibility, and love - most of all love. The writing is beautiful and the ending is as perfect as any I’ve read.
Le Grand Meaulnes by Alain-Fournier
There have been attempts to translate the title (”The Lost Domain” or “The Wanderer”) but it says something of the elusive nature of this French classic that the title is essentially beyond translation. Narrated by one schoolboy, primarily about the exploits of another (Augustin Meaulnes), it details the adventure in which Meaulnes stumbles upon a bizarre fancy dress party at a mysterious chateau and meets the love of his life there. In the wrong hands it could have been disastrous but this novel beautifully explores the concept of the romantic ideal. And of course, the mysterious domain that Meaulnes finds and then loses again is the perfect depiction of adolescent longing. It was the author’s only novel - he was killed in the First World War in 1914, at the age of 27, a year after its publication.
The Grass Harp by Truman Capote
I was tempted to include “To Kill A Mockingbird” and didn’t partly because it was discussed here a few weeks back. But as Capote was a childhood friend of Lee’s and was generally considered to be the model for the character of Dill, it’s fitting that I should choose his wonderful piece of Southern nostalgia instead. It’s an anarchic little story about an orphaned boy, one of his aunts and a servant all going to live in a tree house, and the battle that follows involving the other aunt, the sheriff and the superbly named Judge Cool. Capote at his comic best.
Crazy by Benjamin Lebert
Most coming-of-age books are written with a little distance, but Lebert wrote this semi-autobiographical novel when he was sixteen (he’s only 26 now). There was even talk at the time that he couldn’t have written it himself and that his grandmother might have written it for him. In fact, it’s quite clearly the work of someone very young, full of pompous philosophy and the cliches of adolescent life, because… well, because the author was still mired in adolescence and that’s what it’s like! It’s a slim book and follows a young man with a disability as he goes to a new boarding school. Much of it - a first sexual escapade, for example - has the feel of someone reporting from the frontline. Well worth reading.
The Virgin Suicides by Jeffrey Eugenides
Interestingly, I know a few people who grew up in places like Michigan in the 60s and 70s who really don’t care for this book. Perhaps you need a little distance to appreciate its beauty. Written in the first person plural by an anonymous group of male admirers, it catalogues the suicides of the five Lisbon girls, neatly dovetailing their deaths with the fragility of childhood and adolescence itself. I wasn’t greatly enamoured of Sofia Coppola’s film adaptation, so if anyone else disliked the film, I would urge you not to let that put you off the book.
Spring Night by Tarjei Vesaas
This is a new author to me. I’d often heard that his books were classics that should be read but they’d always been made to sound rather grim. And there is a Bergmanesque quality to his writing (Vesaas was Norwegian, Bergman Swedish) but also a real lightness of touch. This novel deals with a brother and sister, Olaf and Sissel, left on their own for the night in their remote farmhouse when strangers descend upon them, one of them about to give birth. Dramatic events follow and there is very much a coming-of-age during the course of the night, but the novel perfectly captures the febrile and occasionally magical nature of adolescence. There’s also a simple beauty to the writing that many modern writers could learn from - “A tiny morning wind breathed at her dress and played with it. Under it was all of Sissel’s youth.”
Naturally, I’ve immediately thought of several books I should have included on this list, but thems the breaks. Do feel free to comment, to disagree, and of course, to recommend…



















News that Vladimir Nabokov’s son, Dmitri, plans to publish his dad’s last novel (unfinished before the great man’s death) raises for me the question: Given how hard it is to publish while alive, should one publish when dead?
Charleston Heston’s death at 85 has brought a flood of plaudits for his movie roles as Moses, Michelangelo, and Ben-Hur. There was something about Heston’s manner or his era that made him well-suited to play icons. His lesser known historical roles included Andrew Jackson (twice) in ‘The President’s Lady’ and ‘The Buccaneer’, and Rodrigo Diaz de Vivar in ‘El Cid.’
It had never occurred to me that anybody outside France would read Le Grand Meaulnes, I’m impressed!
I would recommend a beautiful book by Jose Mauro de Vasconcelos about a young boy discovering friendship and loss against the backdrop of abject poverty and a difficult family life. The most moving book I have ever read, its English title seems to be My Sweet-Orange Tree.
Comment by Alison — May 14, 2008 @ 1:55 pm
Thanks, Alison. The book you mention, “My Sweet-Orange Tree”, appears to be out of print in English and hard to get hold of (it seems it was first published in 1970/1). This is baffling, not least because one of the editions listed on Amazon has 45 customer reviews, 44 of them giving 5 stars, many describing it as their favourite book.
Comment by Kevin Wignall — May 14, 2008 @ 2:07 pm
“Le Grand Meaulnes” sounds wonderful, Kevin, I’ll have to track down a copy.
I’ve never been a huge fan of coming-of-age novels, because I felt they were forced down my throat in school — I never wanted to read A SEPARATE PEACE, CATCHER IN THE RYE, etc., etc., and resented having to do so very much.
That said, JANE EYRE is my all-time favorite coming of age novel, and that was assigned reading in eighth grade.
Other favorites: WINTER’S BONE, by Daniel Woodrell; ELLEN FOSTER, by Kaye Gibbons, and KATE VAIDEN, by Reynolds Price, which follows its heroine all the way from pre-birth to middle age.
A more recent one is Peter Behrens’s THE LAW OF DREAMS, a great, epic story of a boy’s coming of age during the Potato Famine.
Comment by Clair Lamb — May 14, 2008 @ 6:08 pm
Yes, like youth, I suspect coming-of-age novels are somewhat wasted on the young. I do think you need to be older to fully appreciate the journey undertaken by these characters. And of course, it’s possible that the journey only ever exists with the power of hindsight, which is why Salinger wrote “Catcher in the Rye” in his 30s (and that’s also what makes “Crazy” quite interesting).
Comment by Kevin Wignall — May 14, 2008 @ 7:25 pm
and on the other hand, surely Stealing Beauty is the worst coming of age story of all time? I know it’s a film, but still.
Comment by robin — May 15, 2008 @ 3:01 pm
I don’t know if critics read it this way, but Junot Diaz’s ‘Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao’ could be read in terms of ‘coming of age.’ Oscar’s bumbling and tragic journey through high school is secondary to novel’s larger story of the enduring after-effects of Dominican colonization, slavery, and Trujillismo but I think it’s important to view his quest in the novel’s larger cultural context. I also think it’s one of the few recent award winners that will be read for some time.
Comment by Matt W. — May 16, 2008 @ 5:04 pm